AAEA
Executive Board Meeting Minutes July 25-26, 2003
Montreal, Quebec
Attending:
Jean
Kinsey, Jon Brandt, Susan Offutt, Harry Kaiser, Joseph Glauber,
Susan Capalbo, William Boggess, Catherine Kling, David Zilberman
Ex-Officio:
Donna
Dunn
Guests:
Betty
Eckebrecht, Anne Matthes, Ron Mittelhammer, Laurian Unnevehr,
Peter Berck, Sarahelen (Sally) Thompson was welcomed at 11:00
a.m.
I.
Welcome
Susan
Offutt called the meeting to order at 9:00 a.m.
Donna
Dunn began the meeting with news of the attendance rates for
the 2003 Annual Meeting. As of Tuesday, July 22, there were
1832 total attendees registered for the meeting, 1229 of which
were AAEA members. The room blocks in the three conference hotels
were all filled, meaning that AAEA would not need to pay attrition
to any of the hotels.
Offutt
then welcomed new members Sally Thompson, Ron Mittlehammer and
Laurian Unnevehr to the board.
A.
Minutes of January 2003 Executive Board meeting
i.
Motion to approve the minutes as written made by Jon Brandt,
seconded by Harry Kaiser. Motion carried by unanimous vote.
B.
Minutes of May 22 Executive Board conference call
i.
Motion to approve minutes as written made by Bill Boggess,
seconded by Jean Kinsey. Motion carried by unanimous vote.
C.
Minutes of June 19 Executive Board conference call
i. Motion to approve minutes as written moved by Jon Brandt,
seconded by Harry Kaiser. Motion carried by unanimous vote.
II.
Strategic Issues
A.
AAEA budget and dues
Susan
reviewed the decision made by Executive Board conference call
to raise Association membership dues. This proposal will have
to be brought to the membership of the organization. It will
be done at the annual membership business meeting to be held
on Tuesday, July 19.
Discussion
followed regarding the dues increase. Some of the Executive
Board members had concerns about the increase, but also felt
that proposing the dues increase gives the Association some
direction as to what the members want the Association to be
and makes members think about what they want.
Clarification
was offered as to the status of the Association's services
with the dues increase. It was originally discussed that the
American Journal of Agricultural Economics would start being
offered in an online only format. However, the Board contended
that it should continue to be offered in print format as long
as the financial situation of the Association allows.
Several
Board members pointed out that, with this dues increase, marketing
takes on a much more significant role. The current membership
of the Association has a responsibility to others in the field
of agricultural economics to tout the value of a professional
society as a means to have work published and opportunities
to present research during Annual Meetings.
There
was a discussion on the issue of page charges. It was agreed
by the Board that there is room to assess the current system
of page charges for the AJAE and that benchmarking should
be done against comparable journals. The Board will investigate
increasing the number of pages in the journal.
Offutt
summarized what she would say at the membership meeting. It
would be a combination of information from President-Elect
Jon Brandt's Presidential Address and from her July/August
column in the Exchange. This information summarizes what the
Association is and what services are provided. Then, she will
provide a clear picture of current revenue and expenses while
making the point that the Board has reacted to the reduction
of revenue from investments.
Following,
Offutt will present the membership with the proposed membership
Rate increases.
Regular members--$150
Student members--$75
Senior members--$125
Family members--$275
Industry members--$400
The
Board also agreed that the current policy of being able to
"opt out" of receiving the journals should be discontinued.
All members will receive electronic-only versions of the journals
and will be able to opt out of the print versions.
Motion
that the proposal for dues to be raised as presented and continue
the package of services as it currently stands made by Jean
Kinsey and seconded by Harry Kaiser.
The question was called and motion passed by unanimous vote.
B.
Proposal to AAEA Foundation Board to fund allied organizations
(C-FARE, CAST, COPFAS and COSSA)
Offutt
noted that the current operating policies for the Foundation
indicate that the Foundation is meant to promote the effectiveness
of the discipline, which is what these organizations do. The
Executive Board has been allocating funds to support these
organizations for years, but upon reviewing the operating
policies, it was felt that this would be a more natural fit
for the Foundation. Offutt will take the proposal to the Foundation
Governing Board for their action.
C.
Strategic planning discussion
As AAEA President, Jon Brandt plans to undertake review/revision/recreation
of the AAEA strategic plan in the next year. Given where the
Association is with the budget and the current strategic plan,
Jon would like to see the Board take on the issue of strategic
planning for the January meeting.
The
idea of strategic planning was commended by the Board, although
the suggestion was made to modify the term to "strategic
visioning."
D.
Name and Image Task Force review
There is continuing interest from Steve Buccola to continue
to evaluate the market for agricultural economists in the
marketplace and provide input on that market in respect to
the image of the association.
The
discussion turned to the need for AAEA to be a repository
for baseline information on the profession including demand
for graduates, salaries and number of students. This should
be an ongoing activity of the Association and coordinated
by a standing committee. Offutt suggested that the board recommend
that Buccola turn his attention to the supply and demand of
the Association, containing salary, degree, etc. information.
The
Board determines that the members of this task force should
be advised that a committee is being charged to gather and
maintain this information. The members of the task force will
work with Offutt, Zilberman and Unnevehr from the Board to
create a charge for the committee. Task force members will
also have the opportunity to be the inaugural members of the
committee.
III.
Action/Discussion Items
A.
Finance/budget
Betty Eckebrecht reported on the state of AAEA's finances.
i. Second quarter financial reports
ii. Variance reports
iii. Audit report
iv. Annual Meeting
B.
Expanded searchable membership directory
The new products sub-committee of the Professional Activities
Committee recommends an expanded searchable membership directory.
The expanded directory would enhance the information in the
AAEA database and membership directory. It would allow members
to search on specialty area as well as type of position (government,
industry, teaching, research, Extension). A link to the member's
personal home page would be added.
Cost
estimated at $1,300 for development and annual cost $725.
The Extension Section has offered to pay $750 of the development
costs and would split annual costs between the Extension Section
and the Association
The
Board recommends that this be accepted for the Members Only
area of the Web site, and accepts the Extension Section's
offer for reimbursement. The Board would like the Extension
Section to have an external review of the list to ensure exclusiveness
Harry
Kaiser moved that this proposal be adopted for the Members
Only area of the site. Jon Brandt seconded and the motion
carried by unanimous vote.
C.
Office operations
i. Fiscal year
This is a follow-up from a previous discussion to move AAEA
from a January 1 fiscal year to an April 1 fiscal year. An
April 1 fiscal year would better fit the planning cycle of
the organization, allowing for a smoother workload for accounting
staff. It also allows the Board to vote on the budget before
the start of the fiscal year. Annual audits would fall in
a time of the year when firms charge lower rates. A three-month
short year would take place in the first quarter of 2004,
followed by a 12-month year.
Cathy
Kling moved to change the fiscal year to an April 1-March
31 fiscal year effective in 2004. Joe Glauber seconded the
motion. The motion carried.
D.
AJAE editor and AJAE book review editor
One more AJAE editor and the AJAE book review editor need
to be identified.
i.
Stephen Swallow applied for the second AJAE editor slot that
needs to be filled. Members of the Board received the background
on Swallow who is at the University of Rhode Island. Rhode
Island is going to support his editorship. Swallow has included
a condition in his terms of editorship that he be allowed
to publish in AJAE. The Board determines that they will appoint
him editor without conditions, as the Board is not prepared
to make a decision about editors' publishing at this time.
Jon Brandt moved to appoint Steven Swallow as editor with
the provision that the Communications and Publications Committee
will take up the issue of editors' publishing. Glauber seconded
the motion. Motion approved
ii.
AJAE Book review editor
Peter Berck had an exchange with the current book editor who
has agreed to do it again, and recommends that we offer him
a reappointment of two years.
Motion
to reappoint made by David Zilberman, Joseph Glauber seconded.
The motion carried by unanimous vote.
E.
Selected papers
Jon
Brandt suggested to the Board that the Selected Papers Committee
be turned into a standing committee wherein the chair would
ask people to serve three-year terms in a rotation such that
there would not be complete turnover every year. This would
allow for the committee to benefit from institutional memory.
The
Board would like to continue the current delineation of categories.
The committee could function similar to the awards committee,
with a chair for each category who had previously served on
the committee.
Jon
Brandt moved that a standing committee of the association
be created for selected papers whose chair would be appointed
following the tradition of other committee chairs, where members
are appointed, but serve for three consecutive years. The
motion was seconded by Joseph Glauber
The
motion carried unanimously.
F.
Registration waivers
Offutt proposed that when the Board meets in January, they
discuss a proposal to address the waivers for those who come
to the meetings only for one day to present. The proposal
would create deadlines and criteria.
G.
Fellows discussion
It
was determined that the Fellows discussion is difficult to
have over the phone. The Board recommends attempting to do
the final selection of Fellows during their annual January
meeting
Additionally,
there is no set number that the Fellows Selection Committee
forwards to the Board. However, the Board would like to see
more than eight choices.
IV.
Reports
A.
Committees (reports from the following committees were circulated
to the Board in advance of the meeting)
i. Economics Statistics and Information Resources Committee
ii. Professional Activities
iii. Selected Papers
iv. Employment Services Committee
v. Tellers
vi. Awards
B.
Publications
AJAE - Peter Berck reported to the Board
AAEA is still waiting for access to the digitized library
of AJAE volumes current with the Mann Library at Cornell University.
There is no need for each of the editors to receive ten journals
from Blackwell, Berck suggests that each editor receive three
copies of the journal.
Berck
offered a preview of the issues referred to communications
committee, primarily concerning a move from a four-editor
model to a model where there is one editor who oversees and
make strategic decisions. He also recommended that the honoraria
for the editors be increased incrementally each year.
This was referred to the Communications/Publications Committee
because there is a relationship between the editors, executive
board and the Communications/Publication Committee regarding
the status of the journals and the strategic discussions that
need to take place.
RAE
- Susan Offutt reported to the Board
Statistics show increase in readership of the RAE since the
journal moved to Blackwell.
In 2004, the journal will go to four issues per year, allowing
the journal to be cited in the Social Science Citation Index
as well as becoming more timely.
There is currently an automated system for people to make
sure that papers are moving through the system. The tracking
system that has been built will be turned over to the next
set of editors.
ERS
will turn editorship over in 2004. They encourage an entity
to take this on as a group. The cost to the Association for
this service could be as much as $50,000.
Choices
Editor Peter Barry has resigned. He made a great contribution
by negotiating with Missouri and getting this off the ground.
Brandt will present this issue to the Communications/Publications
Committee.
C.
Sections (reports from the following committees were circulated
to the Board in advance of the meeting)
i. Food and Agricultural Marketing Policy Section
ii. Food Safety and Nutrition Section
iii. Community Economics Section
iv. Seniors Section
V. Other Business
A. Committee and Section Board liaisons must be chosen
i. Committees
· Communication/Publications: Harry Kaiser
· Employment Services: Ron Mittlehammer
· ESIRC: David Zilberman
· Fellows selection: Susan Offutt
· Finance: Bill Bogguss, Susan Capalbo, Sally Thompson
· International (turning into section): Laurian Unnevehr
· Nominating committee: Susan Offutt
· Selected Papers: Jon Brandt
· Professional Activities: Ron Mittlehammer
ii. Sections
· FAMPS: Sally Thompson
· Extension: Jon Brandt
· Food Safety: Laurian Unnevehr
· Seniors: Susan Capalbo
· IBES: Harry Kaiser
· CENET: Laurian Unnevehr
· CWAE: Bill Boggess
· COSBAE: Jon Brandt
· GSS: Bill Boggess
· NAAEA: Jon Brandt
· TLC: Susan Capalbo
· AEM: Harry Kaiser
iii. Foundation: David Zilberman, Sally Thompson and Susan
Offutt
B.
C-FARE
Gene Nelson, Chair of C-FARE presented to the Board his vision
for C-FARE. The group would like to see funding divided up
four ways:
1. Department heads
2. USDA, Economic Research Service
3. Other federal agencies
4. AAEA
C-FARE
would also support Choices in the following ways:
· Marketing, making information available
· Focus groups to identify issues
· Create "fact sheets" for quick overview
VII.
Comments from outgoing Board Members:
Kinsey, Glauber and Kling commented on their Board service and
their perceptions on the Association and the Association's future.
VII.
Adjourn
Motion to adjourn made by Jon Brandt, seconded by Jean Kinsey.
The meeting adjourned at 9:45 a.m.